Check Your Claims
Legal News Healthcare

Allegheny Health Network and Highmark sued over Abridge AI recordings of patient visits

A Pittsburgh-area patient has sued Allegheny Health Network and its parent, Highmark Health, claiming the Abridge AI tool recorded doctor visits and sent the audio to an outside company without the consent Pennsylvania law requires. The suit seeks class status for AHN patients. Nothing is proven and there is no settlement.

By Class Action Pulse Staff Published

Reported from primary sources · Verified against official filings and settlement records.

Estimated reading time: 8 minutes.

Key facts

  • What happened: A patient identified only as H.R. has filed a proposed class action against Allegheny Health Network (AHN) and its parent company, Highmark Health, in the Court of Common Pleas of Allegheny County, Pennsylvania. The complaint is dated November 3, 2026.
  • The claim: The complaint says AHN clinicians used Abridge, an artificial intelligence (AI) recording tool, to capture full exam-room conversations and send them to an outside company, Abridge AI, Inc., without the informed, all-party consent the plaintiff says Pennsylvania law requires.
  • Who it would cover: People who attended an appointment at a Pennsylvania facility operated by or affiliated with AHN during which Abridge was activated, from the date the defendants deployed Abridge to the date of any class certification.
  • Legal claims: Pennsylvania's wiretap law, breach of physician-patient confidentiality, invasion of privacy, negligence, breach of implied contract and unjust enrichment.
  • Money: There is no settlement, payment or claim form. The plaintiff asks for damages, including the minimum amounts set by Pennsylvania's wiretap law, but a court has not decided anything.
  • Status: These are allegations. AHN and Highmark have not filed a public response that we could find, and Abridge AI, Inc. is not a defendant.

In this article

Many doctors now use AI "scribes" that listen to an appointment and draft the visit note, so the clinician can look at the patient instead of a keyboard. A new lawsuit in Pittsburgh asks whether patients at one of Western Pennsylvania's largest health systems were told enough about where those recordings go.

The complaint, H.R. v. Allegheny Health Network and Highmark Health, was filed in state court by lawyers from Siri & Glimstad LLP and Chestnut Cambronne PA. The copy we reviewed does not show a docket number.

What the lawsuit claims

The plaintiff's central argument is short. "A hospital cannot unilaterally decide to record a private conversation and hand that recording to an outside company to keep and use for its own purposes," the complaint says.

According to the complaint, AHN began using Abridge no later than March 2024. Once a clinician switches it on, the tool records the entire conversation, sends the audio to Abridge AI, Inc.'s servers and returns a draft note that goes into the patient's electronic health record. The plaintiff alleges, "upon information and belief," that Abridge AI, Inc. keeps the conversations and uses them to train its own commercial AI models.

The complaint says some patients "were told nothing at all," while others heard only a passing reference to an AI tool. Neither group, it argues, agreed to what actually happened.

What this case is about The lawsuit does not argue that AI scribes are illegal. It argues that AHN's notice to patients was too thin to count as consent under Pennsylvania law. A court has not ruled on that question.

Who the parties are

The plaintiff. H.R. is an Allegheny County resident who sued under initials and filed a motion asking to proceed under a pseudonym. The complaint lists 11 visits with AHN-affiliated providers between October 29, 2024 and June 1, 2026. It says she discussed her mental health, addiction and treatment during those visits and was told, at most, that an AI tool would be used.

Allegheny Health Network. AHN is a Pittsburgh-based nonprofit health system. The complaint describes it as operating more than a dozen hospitals and hundreds of physician offices, outpatient centers and clinics in Western Pennsylvania.

Highmark Health. Highmark is AHN's parent company and also the parent of Highmark Inc., a health insurer. The complaint says Highmark's insurer and its affiliates serve more than seven million members and that about half of AHN's patients are insured by Highmark. It alleges that Highmark selected Abridge for the whole enterprise and announced on August 12, 2025, that the platform would be deployed across AHN's hospitals and outpatient locations.

Abridge AI, Inc. Abridge is the company behind the recording tool. It is not named as a defendant. The complaint cites reports that Abridge raised $300 million in June 2025 at a valuation of about $5.3 billion.

How ambient AI documentation works

"Ambient" means the tool listens in the background rather than waiting for dictation. According to the complaint, these tools combine two technologies. Automated speech recognition (ASR) turns spoken words into text. A large language model (LLM), the same kind of technology behind consumer chatbots, then reads that text and writes a structured clinical note.

Because the model needs the full transcript to write an accurate note, the complaint says, the tool captures everything said in the room: symptoms, diagnoses, medication history, family history and mental health disclosures. It also alleges that Abridge's "Linked Evidence" feature lets a note be traced back to the source transcript and audio, which the plaintiff says shows the recordings are kept after the note is written.

The complaint also says Highmark and Abridge announced they were building a "real-time" prior authorization tool that compares an insurer's requirements with information gathered during the visit. Prior authorization is an insurer's advance approval for a treatment. The plaintiff argues this gave Highmark its own interest in the recorded conversations.

On model training, the complaint points to a June 11, 2026, Abridge announcement of a clinical foundation model built with Nvidia on de-identified data, meaning data with names and direct identifiers removed. The plaintiff alleges, on information and belief, that such training data comes from encounters like those at AHN.

Why Pennsylvania wiretap law matters here

The lead claim is under the Pennsylvania Wiretapping and Electronic Surveillance Control Act (WESCA). Pennsylvania is an "all-party consent" state. In general, recording a private oral conversation is lawful only if everyone in the conversation agrees beforehand.

WESCA also gives people whose conversations are unlawfully intercepted the right to sue. The law allows actual damages, but not less than liquidated damages of $100 a day for each day of violation or $1,000, whichever is higher, plus possible punitive damages and attorneys' fees. Liquidated damages are fixed amounts set by statute that do not require proof of a specific dollar loss. Whether any of that applies here depends on what a court decides about consent.

The other claims draw on older duties. "Intrusion upon seclusion" is a privacy claim for highly offensive intrusions into private matters. Unjust enrichment means AHN and Highmark allegedly gained benefits they should not keep.

The key legal question Pennsylvania generally requires every party's prior consent to record a private conversation. The fight is likely to center on whether a brief mention of AI, where one was given, counts as consent to recording and outside processing.

What patients were allegedly told

The complaint describes AHN's approach as a centrally designed "Notice Protocol." According to the plaintiff, it never told patients that:

  • the whole conversation would be recorded as audio;
  • the audio would go to an outside company, Abridge AI, Inc.;
  • recordings or derived data could be kept or used to improve Abridge's products;
  • how long recordings would be kept or how to delete them;
  • every person in the room, including family members and caregivers, needed to agree.

The plaintiff also alleges that patients got no advance notice before the day of the visit, that nothing visible or audible in the room showed when recording was active, and that clinicians were neither trained nor instructed to give the missing disclosures. These are allegations "upon information and belief," which means the plaintiff expects to prove them through records obtained in the case.

Who could be included

The proposed class covers all natural persons who, between the date the defendants deployed Abridge and the date of class certification, attended a medical appointment at a Pennsylvania facility operated by or affiliated with AHN during which Abridge was activated to record, transcribe or process the encounter.

The proposal excludes the defendants and their affiliates, officers and directors; their employees, agents and affiliated providers, and interpreters who took part in a recorded conversation on their behalf; and the judge and court staff.

The complaint says that by August 2025 about 400 AHN providers in more than 40 specialties were using Abridge. It does not give a patient count, saying only that the defendants' records likely reflect "many thousands" of qualifying visits. No class has been certified.

What the plaintiff is asking for

The complaint asks the court to certify the class, declare that the recordings violated WESCA, issue unspecified injunctive relief, and award actual, statutory, liquidated, punitive and nominal damages, restitution, attorneys' fees and interest. The plaintiff demands a jury trial.

What is not yet known

  • A docket number and judge. The public copy does not show them.
  • The defendants' side. We did not find a public statement from AHN, Highmark or Abridge about this lawsuit. Reports summarizing local Pittsburgh coverage said a spokesperson for AHN and Highmark declined to comment.
  • The actual contract terms. The claims about Abridge's data use and the AHN agreement are made on information and belief.
  • Whether there is a second suit. Some reports dated October 30 described a Pittsburgh-area woman's lawsuit over the same tool filed that day with different personal details. We could not confirm whether that describes this complaint or a separate case.

A similar proposed class action was filed in November 2025 against Sharp HealthCare in San Diego Superior Court, according to KPBS. That case is under California law and involves different facts.

Case timeline

  • No later than March 2024: AHN begins using Abridge, according to the complaint.
  • August 12, 2025: Highmark and Abridge announce an enterprise-wide deployment across AHN.
  • June 11, 2026: Abridge announces a clinical foundation model with Nvidia.
  • November 3, 2026: Date on the H.R. complaint.
  • November 4 and 10, 2026: Law360 and ClassAction.org report on the suit.

What happens next

The complaint's notice tells the defendants they have 20 days after service to enter an appearance and file defenses or objections. In Pennsylvania state court, defendants often respond with preliminary objections, a filing that challenges whether the complaint states a valid claim. The plaintiff would later need to ask the court to certify the class.

For AHN patients There is nothing to file and no money available. If you were seen at AHN since 2024, your visit notes in the patient portal may show whether an AI tool was used. This is general information, not legal advice.

You can follow other open cases in our list of class action cases you can join.

Frequently asked questions

What is the AHN Abridge lawsuit about?

A patient claims Allegheny Health Network and Highmark Health recorded exam-room conversations with the Abridge AI tool and sent them to Abridge AI, Inc. without informed, all-party consent under Pennsylvania law.

Is Abridge being sued?

No. The complaint names only AHN and Highmark Health. It describes Abridge AI, Inc.'s role but does not make it a defendant.

Who would be in the class?

People who had an appointment at a Pennsylvania AHN-operated or affiliated facility where Abridge was activated, from deployment until class certification. The court has not certified any class.

Can I get money from this lawsuit?

Not now. There is no settlement or claim form. The plaintiff seeks damages, including Pennsylvania wiretap law's minimum amounts, but nothing has been awarded.

Did AHN admit wrongdoing?

No. AHN and Highmark have not admitted anything, and no court has made findings. We found no public response from them.

How can I tell if Abridge was used at my visit?

The complaint says Abridge notes go into the electronic health record. Reviewing your visit notes or asking AHN directly may help. Keep records of your visits in case a class is certified.

Sources

Class Action Pulse is a news and information service, not a law firm, and this article is general information — not legal advice. Eligibility, deadlines, and payouts are set by each settlement's official administrator and the courts; always verify the details through the official source before you file.