Estimated reading time: 8 minutes.
Key facts
- Case: Ellsworth v. Hatch Baby, Inc., No. 5:26-cv-12842, U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California, San Jose Division.
- Filed: October 30, 2026.
- Products: The Hatch Rest Go portable sound machine and the newer Hatch Go, which the complaint calls substantially similar.
- What is alleged: Hatch sold the machines for use close to babies without warning parents about the risk of noise-induced hearing loss at high volume, close range or long use.
- What the plaintiff wants: Money for buyers who say they overpaid, plus a court order requiring warnings or corrective action, which could include a recall or replacement.
- Status: Newly filed proposed class action. Hatch has not responded in court, and no class has been certified. There is no settlement or claim form.
In this article
- What the lawsuit claims
- The products and the plaintiff
- The science the complaint relies on
- What Hatch has told parents
- The legal claims
- Who could be included
- What is still unknown
- What parents can do now
- Frequently asked questions
A California mother has sued Hatch Baby, the company behind some of the most popular baby sound machines in the U.S., claiming its portable Rest Go and Hatch Go devices can play loud enough, close enough to a baby's ears to risk hearing damage, and that Hatch never told parents.
The lawsuit does not claim any child was hurt. It is an economic case: it argues parents paid for a product they would not have bought, or would have paid less for, if they had known about the risk.
What the lawsuit claims
The complaint was filed October 30, 2026, in federal court in San Jose by Kristin Ellsworth. It says scientific, medical and regulatory groups have concluded that white noise can pose a hearing loss risk to children when it is played "at too high of a volume, when located too close to the child's ears, and when used for too long of a period of time."
According to the complaint, Hatch knew about that risk, did not disclose it on its packaging or in its marketing, and instead encouraged parents to use the devices right next to their children. It says Hatch advertised the Rest Go and Hatch Go as devices to attach to strollers, cribs and car seats, and to two customer quotes Hatch used: "My two-year-old likes wearing it as a bracelet" and that it was "loud enough to keep [a child] asleep in a crowded restaurant."
The complaint also says Hatch now sells the Hatch Go with a "30-Night Bedside Trial" offer.
This is not an injury lawsuit The complaint seeks refunds and overpayment damages for buyers. It does not allege that the plaintiff's child or any other child suffered hearing loss from a Hatch device.
The products and the plaintiff
Hatch Baby is a Delaware company headquartered in Palo Alto, California. The complaint says its sound machines are sold on Hatch.co in the U.S. and Canada, through most major retailers and on Amazon. The Hatch Go retails for $39.99, according to the complaint. It also cites a YouTube video claiming Hatch had $40 million in sales after its founders appeared on the TV show "Shark Tank."
Ellsworth lives in Irvine, California. She says she bought a Hatch Rest Go on Amazon on November 24, 2023, for about $34.99. She is represented by Tom Wheeler Law of Glendale, California, and the Philadelphia firm Feldman Shepherd Wohlgelernter Tanner Weinstock & Dodig.
The science the complaint relies on
Sound is measured in decibels. The complaint leans on several sources to argue that infants need much lower limits than adults:
- NICU design standards: Recommended standards for newborn intensive care units say continuous sound in a baby's bed space should not exceed an hourly average of 50 dBA, with brief peaks no higher than 70 dBA.
- American Academy of Pediatrics: The complaint cites the group's 2023 policy statement on preventing excessive noise exposure in children. When announcing that statement, the AAP said: "Excessive noise exposure is a serious public health hazard that goes largely unrecognized."
- Adult workplace limits do not fit babies: The complaint says the widely used 85 dBA for eight hours limit from the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health was built for adult workers, and quotes the World Health Organization saying those standards "were not designed to consider vulnerable populations such as children."
It also cites a 2014 study in the journal Pediatrics that measured sound levels from infant sleep machines.
One important gap: Class Action Pulse did not find sound-level measurements of the Hatch Rest Go or Hatch Go themselves in the complaint. The filing states that Hatch's machines exceed safe limits, but its support comes from general standards and earlier research rather than reported tests of these specific devices. Whether the products can actually reach harmful levels at the distances parents use them will be a central factual question.
What Hatch has told parents
The complaint points to a Hatch blog post from January 19, 2024, titled "Safe Sleep Sounds: What Parents Should Know." It argues the post shows Hatch knew about the risk but kept the information off its packaging and product pages, and that the post wrongly suggests a machine is safe unless it exceeds 85 decibels.
Read in full, the Hatch post gives parents more context than that. It says the 2014 study found that, at maximum volume, many infant sleep machines exceeded 85 decibels when placed 30 cm or 100 cm from a crib, but that "when the sound machine was placed 200 cm from the crib, or across the room, none of the machines exceeded 85 decibels." It notes that NICUs use an average of 50 decibels as a benchmark, which "can be a good target volume for your white noise machine at home," and recommends placing the machine far from the child's sleeping space.
Hatch had not publicly responded to the lawsuit when this article was published, and Class Action Pulse did not find a statement from the company.
The core dispute Hatch's own blog advises lower volume and more distance. The lawsuit argues that advice needed to be on the product and in the marketing, not in a separate blog post, especially for a device sold to clip onto strollers and cribs.
The legal claims
The complaint argues that Hatch had a duty to disclose the risk, pointing to federal product safety rules that require companies to report products that may create an unreasonable risk of serious injury and to the Federal Hazardous Substances Act's labeling requirements. It brings 10 claims:
- California Consumers Legal Remedies Act: bars deceptive practices in consumer sales.
- California Unfair Competition Law: prohibits unlawful, unfair or fraudulent business practices.
- California False Advertising Law: bans untrue or misleading advertising.
- Breach of contract and breach of implied contract: claims buyers did not get what they bargained for.
- Breach of implied and express warranties: claims the products were not fit for their marketed use.
- Song-Beverly Consumer Warranty Act: California's consumer warranty law.
- Negligent misrepresentation: claims Hatch should have known its marketing was misleading.
- Unjust enrichment: claims Hatch profited unfairly from the sales.
The complaint says Ellsworth sent Hatch a written notice letter on March 20, 2025, and that Hatch did not take corrective action. It asks for damages, restitution, an injunction requiring corrective action "including notification, recall, and fully-covered replacement parts and labor or replacement" devices, attorneys' fees and a jury trial.
Who could be included
The complaint proposes three groups:
- Nationwide class: everyone in the U.S. who bought the sound machines for personal use, not for resale.
- Multi-state class: buyers in California, Florida, Illinois, Massachusetts, Michigan, Minnesota, Missouri, New Jersey, New York and Washington, under those states' consumer protection laws.
- California class: buyers in California.
These groups are only proposals. A judge must certify a class before anyone is formally part of the case, and that usually happens much later, if at all.
No claim form yet Nothing has been settled, so there is no payment to claim. Be cautious of any site that asks for personal or payment details in exchange for a Hatch payout.
What is still unknown
Hatch has not filed a response, and its defenses are not yet known. The court has not ruled on any of the claims, and no one is entitled to money right now. It is also unclear whether a court would allow a nationwide class or limit the case to certain states.
What parents can do now
If you bought a Hatch Rest Go or Hatch Go, keep your receipt or order confirmation in case a settlement or class certification happens later. You do not need to do anything to stay eligible for a possible future class.
Separately from the lawsuit, Hatch's own guidance and pediatric groups point in the same direction: keep sound machines at a low volume, away from the crib or stroller, and talk to your pediatrician about safe levels.
For cases you may be able to join now, see our list of class action cases you can join. This article is general information, not legal advice.
Frequently asked questions
What is the Hatch sound machine lawsuit about?
A proposed class action filed October 30, 2026, claims Hatch failed to warn parents that its Rest Go and Hatch Go sound machines can pose a hearing loss risk to babies when played loudly, close to the ear or for long periods.
Which Hatch products are included?
The complaint covers the Hatch Rest Go and the newer Hatch Go, which it says is substantially similar. It does not name other Hatch products.
Did the lawsuit say a baby lost hearing?
No. The complaint is about economic harm. It argues buyers overpaid or would not have bought the devices if they had known about the risk.
Is there a Hatch recall?
The lawsuit asks the court to order corrective action that could include a recall or replacement. No court has ordered that, and the complaint does not cite an existing recall.
Can I join the Hatch lawsuit?
There is no claim form. If a class is certified or a settlement is reached, buyers would typically be notified. Keeping your proof of purchase is a sensible step.
What has Hatch said?
Class Action Pulse did not find a public response to the lawsuit. A 2024 Hatch blog post advises parents to use lower volumes and place sound machines far from where a child sleeps.

