Check Your Claims
Legal News Consumer

McDonald's hit with second 'sugar free' McCafé lawsuit, this time over eight drinks

Three customers in Illinois, California and New York sued McDonald's on November 6, 2026, saying eight McCafé 'Sugar Free' lattes, cappuccinos and iced coffees contain up to 18 grams of sugar from milk. The suit proposes a nationwide class. There is no settlement or claim form.

By Class Action Pulse Staff Published

Reported from primary sources · Verified against official filings and settlement records.

Sugar in a large

How much sugar the 'Sugar Free' drinks contain

Grams of sugar in a large size, as the complaint reports from McDonald's own nutrition pages, compared with the federal sugar free limit of under 0.5 grams per serving. The complaint says sugar figures for the four renamed 'Vanilla' drinks were not published.

36 times the 0.5 gram limit per large serving, per the complaint.

Source: Camacho v. McDonald's complaint, paragraphs 8 and 31

Estimated reading time: 9 minutes.

Key facts

  • What happened: Three McDonald's customers filed a proposed class action on November 6, 2026, saying eight McCafé coffee drinks sold with "Sugar Free" in their names contain between 2 and 18 grams of sugar in a large size.
  • The core claim: Federal food rules allow a "sugar free" claim only below 0.5 grams of sugar per serving. The complaint says the sugar comes from lactose in the milk or cream, and that lactose counts.
  • The rename: The complaint says McDonald's began renaming some drinks "Reduced Sugar" after a similar Starbucks lawsuit in October, but still described them as sugar free in some delivery app listings.
  • Who it would cover: A proposed nationwide class of U.S. buyers from three years before the filing, with backup classes for Illinois, California and New York. No class has been certified.
  • The case: Camacho et al. v. McDonald's Corporation and McDonald's USA, LLC, No. 1:26-cv-13821 (N.D. Ill.).

In this article

What happened

Abigail Camacho of Chicago, Alfredo Aguilar of Azusa, California, and LaTonya Wright of Brooklyn, New York, filed a complaint in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Illinois, the federal trial court in Chicago, on November 6, 2026.

They say eight McCafé drinks named "Sugar Free" contain up to 18 grams of sugar in a large size, by McDonald's own nutrition figures, and lack a calorie warning federal rules require with that claim.

It is the second proposed class action over McCafé "Sugar Free" drinks in a month. A Bronx customer sued McDonald's in New York federal court on October 19, 2026 over four of the same drinks.

Who the parties are

McDonald's Corporation is the fast-food company behind the McDonald's restaurant chain. The complaint says it is a Delaware corporation headquartered at 110 N. Carpenter Street in Chicago. McDonald's USA, LLC is described in the complaint, on information and belief, as a wholly owned subsidiary that franchises the McDonald's system to independent restaurant owners, runs mcdonalds.com and the mobile ordering app, and sets the recipe every U.S. restaurant must use for these drinks.

"On information and belief" means the plaintiffs believe something is true but do not yet have direct proof.

Camacho says she bought the drinks in Chicago from about 2023, Aguilar in Covina and Glendora, California from about October 2024, and Wright in Brooklyn from about 2019. Each says they read "Sugar Free" to mean no sugar and never saw the sugar content before buying.

They are represented by Hagens Berman Sobol Shapiro and Sterlington PLLC. In a November 6 announcement, Hagens Berman partner Steve Berman said "'sugar free' means zero sugar" and that "Consumers deserve to have accurate information about the foods they purchase to make the best choices for their health."

Which McCafe drinks are named

The complaint lists eight drinks:

  • Sugar Free French Vanilla Latte
  • Sugar Free French Vanilla Cappuccino
  • Sugar Free Iced French Vanilla Latte
  • Iced Sugar Free French Vanilla Coffee
  • Sugar Free Vanilla Latte
  • Sugar Free Vanilla Cappuccino
  • Sugar Free Iced Vanilla Latte
  • Iced Sugar Free Vanilla Coffee

According to the complaint, McDonald's own website lists 18, 12, 11 and 2 grams of sugar for large sizes of the four French vanilla drinks, in that order. The lawyers say they could not find sugar figures for the four "Vanilla" versions, which they believe replaced the "French Vanilla" names around spring 2026. They assume the sugar content is about the same because the milk or cream is the same.

Who may be affected Anyone who bought one of these eight drinks in the U.S. for personal use in the last few years could fall within the proposed class. That is not a finding. A judge has to certify a class first.

How the sugar free rule works

The U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) sets rules for "nutrient content claims," which are words on food like "low fat" or "sugar free" that describe how much of a nutrient something has. Under 21 C.F.R. 101.60(c)(1), a product can be called "sugar free" only if it has less than 0.5 grams of sugar per reference amount and per labeled serving.

The reference amount customarily consumed, or RACC, is the standard portion size the FDA uses for a type of food. The complaint says it is 360 milliliters, or 12 fluid ounces, for these coffee drinks. Using its own estimate of 22 ounces for a large, the complaint says the drinks carry about 2.2 to 19.9 times the limit per reference amount and 4 to 36 times the limit per large serving.

Lactose is the natural sugar in milk. The FDA's definition of "total sugars" names lactose directly, alongside glucose, fructose and sucrose. That is the heart of the case. The plaintiffs do not say McDonald's adds table sugar. They say the sugar in the milk or cream still counts.

The same rule has a second requirement. A "sugar free" food that is not also low calorie or reduced calorie must carry a statement such as "not a reduced calorie food," "not a low calorie food" or "not for weight control." The complaint says McDonald's used none of these statements anywhere.

What the complaint alleges

These are the plaintiffs' claims. McDonald's has not admitted them, and no court has ruled on them.

  • The name itself is false. The suit argues "Sugar Free" is part of each drink's official name, which makes it the most prominent thing a buyer sees.
  • The sugar figures are hard to find. It says sugar content does not appear on in-store or drive-through menu boards or on ordering kiosk product pages, and that the drinks carry no nutrition labels. On mcdonalds.com, it says, the numbers appear only if a visitor clicks to reveal them, on product pages reached through search rather than the menu. The names also appear in the McDonald's app and on DoorDash, Uber Eats and Grubhub, according to the complaint.
  • Restaurant food is covered. The complaint cites an FDA rule, 21 C.F.R. 101.13(q)(5), that applies nutrient claim rules to food served in restaurants.
  • The rename shows awareness. It says that after the Starbucks complaint and the media attention it drew, McDonald's began renaming some drinks "Reduced Sugar." It quotes a DoorDash description of the "Reduced SUGAR VANILLA CAPPUCCINO" that still calls it "A warm, comforting Sugar Free French Vanilla Cappuccino."
  • The new name is also a problem. A "reduced sugar" claim must mean at least 25% less sugar than a comparison food, and the label must name that food and the percentage. The complaint says the renamed listings name no reference food and give no percentage.

The plaintiffs say they are not asking for any disclosure beyond what federal law already requires. That matters because federal law bars states from imposing food labeling rules that differ from the FDA's.

The key legal question The case turns on whether milk sugar in a coffee drink makes a "sugar free" name misleading under state consumer laws that mirror FDA rules. McDonald's has not yet answered that argument in court.

The federal Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act does not let consumers sue directly. So the plaintiffs sue under state consumer protection laws and use the FDA rules as evidence that the name is false and misleading.

The complaint brings seven counts:

  • Illinois Consumer Fraud and Deceptive Business Practices Act, for a nationwide class. The plaintiffs argue Illinois law should apply to everyone because the naming decisions were made at the Chicago headquarters.
  • California Unfair Competition Law, in three counts covering its "unlawful," "unfair" and "fraudulent" prongs, along with California's False Advertising Law.
  • California Consumers Legal Remedies Act, a state law against deceptive practices in consumer sales.
  • New York General Business Law sections 349 and 350, which bar deceptive business practices and false advertising.
  • Unjust enrichment, a claim that a company should not keep money it received unfairly.

Who could be part of the case

The main proposed class is "All persons in the United States who purchased one or more of the Sugar Free Products for personal, family, or household use from three years prior to the filing of this Complaint through the date of class certification."

If a judge will not certify a nationwide class, the plaintiffs ask in the alternative for separate Illinois, California and New York subclasses covering the same time frame. McDonald's, its officers, directors, employees and franchisees, the judge and the plaintiffs' lawyers are excluded.

The lawsuit asks for a court declaration that the names are unlawful, an order barring "sugar free" names on drinks over the federal limit, refunds, damages, punitive damages where state law allows them, and attorneys' fees. These are requests, not awards. No money is available.

Timeline and case status

  • October 2, 2026: A similar complaint is filed against Starbucks in federal court in Seattle over "sugar free" drinks.
  • October 19, 2026: A Bronx customer files Mercado v. McDonald's Corporation, No. 1:26-cv-09142, in the Southern District of New York over four McCafé "Sugar Free" drinks.
  • After October 2, 2026: McDonald's begins replacing "Sugar Free" with "Reduced Sugar" in some drink names, the complaint says.
  • November 6, 2026: The Camacho complaint is filed in Chicago.
  • November 7, 2026: The docket shows the case assigned to Judge Matthew F. Kennelly.

The case is at the complaint stage. The court docket shows it is assigned to U.S. District Judge Matthew F. Kennelly. As of November 7, the docket showed no response from McDonald's.

What is known and what is not

Known: the drink names, the sugar figures the complaint cites, the claims and the proposed classes.

Not known: sugar figures for the "Vanilla" drinks, how McDonald's will respond, whether this case will be combined with the New York case, and whether the renaming is complete. Class Action Pulse found no public statement from McDonald's about this lawsuit.

What happens next

McDonald's will need to answer the complaint or file a motion to dismiss. Companies in labeling cases often argue federal law preempts the claims or that a reasonable buyer would not be misled. If the case survives, the plaintiffs would later ask the court to certify a class.

The two McDonald's cases could also be coordinated or transferred.

What to do now There is nothing to file yet. If you bought these drinks, saving app order history or card statements may help if a settlement ever opens.

You can follow the earlier New York case on our McCafé sugar free case page or browse other open class action cases.

Frequently asked questions

Is there a McDonald's sugar free settlement?

No. The lawsuit was filed November 6, 2026. There is no settlement, claim form or deadline.

Does McDonald's add sugar to these drinks?

The lawsuit does not say McDonald's adds table sugar. It says the sugar comes from lactose in the milk or cream, and that federal rules count lactose.

Which drinks are part of the lawsuit?

The eight McCafé "Sugar Free" vanilla and French vanilla lattes, iced lattes, cappuccinos and iced coffees listed above.

Is this the same as the New York McDonald's lawsuit?

No. It is a separate case filed in Illinois by different plaintiffs and lawyers. It names eight drinks instead of four and adds claims about the "Reduced Sugar" rename.

Do I need to be diabetic or lactose intolerant?

No. The proposed class is based on buying the drinks for personal use, not on any health condition.

Has McDonald's responded?

Class Action Pulse found no public response to this lawsuit in the sources reviewed.