Check Your Claims
Legal News Consumer

StubHub asks court to send World Cup ticket class action to arbitration

StubHub filed a motion on October 14, 2026, asking a New York federal judge to send fans' consolidated World Cup ticket class action to individual arbitration or dismiss it. The fans' opposition is due November 13 and StubHub's reply December 4. Nothing has been decided and there is no settlement.

By Class Action Pulse Staff Published

Reported from primary sources · Verified against official filings and settlement records.

Estimated reading time: 9 minutes.

Key facts

  • Case: In re StubHub World Cup Ticket Marketing & Sales Litigation, No. 1:26-cv-05569, U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York, before Judge Vernon S. Broderick.
  • What it is about: fans who say they bought 2026 FIFA World Cup tickets on StubHub and did not receive them as promised.
  • Latest step: on October 14, 2026, StubHub filed a motion to compel arbitration or, in the alternative, to dismiss the consolidated complaint.
  • Upcoming deadlines: the fans' opposition is due November 13, 2026, and StubHub's reply is due December 4, 2026, under a court-approved schedule.
  • Why it matters: if the judge sends the claims to arbitration, buyers would generally have to pursue them one at a time instead of as a class.
  • Status: no ruling on the motion, no class certification, no settlement and no claim form.

In this article

StubHub has asked a federal judge in New York to send a class action over undelivered 2026 World Cup tickets out of court and into private arbitration. If granted, fans would generally have to bring their claims one at a time.

The motion, filed October 14, 2026, is the first major test for the consolidated case, which combines lawsuits filed by World Cup ticket buyers this summer. The fans' lawyers have until November 13 to respond.

What StubHub is asking the court to do

According to the court docket, StubHub filed a "Motion to Compel Arbitration or, in the Alternative, to Dismiss the First Consolidated Amended Complaint," along with a supporting legal memorandum and a declaration from James Wright. Docket descriptions say the declaration attaches StubHub's 2025 User Agreement, its 2022 User Agreement and its Canadian User Agreement.

The title shows the order of the request: arbitration first, and dismissal only if the judge refuses to send the case to arbitration.

The memorandum explaining StubHub's arguments was not publicly available on free court record services when Class Action Pulse reviewed the docket. That means the specific reasons StubHub gives, and which version of its terms it says applies to which buyers, are not yet known to us. We will update this article if the filing becomes available.

A motion is a request, not a ruling StubHub's filing asks the judge to act. Nothing has been decided, and the fans will file their opposition before the judge considers the request.

How the World Cup ticket case began

The first lawsuit was filed June 30, 2026, by California residents Julie Reeker Moghal and Reuben Renteria. Their complaint, which has since been replaced by a consolidated version, described what happened to them:

  • Moghal said she paid StubHub $1,905 for three tickets to a June 18 match at SoFi Stadium in Los Angeles. She said StubHub cancelled her order, then promised to deliver tickets an hour before the match. She said she waited at the stadium, never received them and was not refunded.
  • Renteria said he paid $2,294.69 for two tickets to the June 18 Mexico vs. Korea match in Mexico and traveled there for the game. He said his order was cancelled, he could not attend and he was refunded on June 25 without explanation, after already spending money on travel.

The original complaint quoted StubHub's FanProtect Guarantee, which says the company "back[s] every order so you can buy and sell tickets with 100% confidence." It also cited FIFA's resale terms, which describe FIFA's own marketplace as the tournament's "only authorized" resale platform and warn that tickets from third parties "may be invalid." The complaint brought claims under the federal Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act and California consumer protection laws, plus a conversion claim, and proposed a nationwide class and a California subclass of people who bought World Cup tickets through StubHub and did not receive them as promised.

A second case, Stasium v. StubHub, was filed July 7. On July 10 the court combined the two and appointed Blake Hunter Yagman of Yagman PLLC and Kevin Laukaitis of Laukaitis Law as interim co-lead counsel for the proposed class. A filing in late August listed 19 named plaintiffs.

After two earlier attempts were rejected for filing errors, the plaintiffs filed their First Consolidated Amended Class Action Complaint on September 14, 2026. That document is not available on free public record services, so Class Action Pulse cannot say exactly which claims or class definitions it contains.

On September 17, the judge approved a schedule agreed to by both sides. It cited "the size of the putative class, the number of claims asserted, and the length of the Consolidated Amended Class Action Complaint" and allowed StubHub's supporting declaration to run up to 30 pages.

What the arbitration clause says

StubHub's current Global User Agreement, dated December 2025, says U.S. and Canadian residents agree to resolve disputes through binding arbitration run by the American Arbitration Association, rather than in court. Key terms include:

  • Class action waiver: claims can be brought only on an individual basis, not as a class or representative action.
  • Small claims exception: individual claims can go to small claims court if they qualify.
  • Fees: for claims of $10,000 or less, StubHub says it will pay the filing, administration and arbitrator fees at the customer's request.
  • Opt out: customers can reject arbitration by mailing a signed notice within 30 days of first accepting the agreement, or within 30 days of notice that the arbitration terms changed.
  • Notice first: a person must mail a Notice of Dispute and wait 30 days before starting arbitration.
  • Governing law: the Federal Arbitration Act governs the clause, and California law governs disputes for U.S. and Canadian residents.

The clause says it covers disputes relating to "this or previous versions" of the agreement. It does not apply to people who buy tickets for events in British Columbia.

The plaintiffs saw this fight coming. Their original complaint argued that StubHub's terms say arbitration does not apply when a dispute remains and has been reported to federal authorities, and it said their lawyer reported the dispute to the Federal Trade Commission on June 30. Class Action Pulse did not find an exception matching that description in the U.S. and Canada arbitration section of the current agreement. A separate clause for Mexico residents says disputes may be submitted to Mexico's federal consumer protection agency. It is not clear which language the plaintiffs relied on, and the consolidated complaint may argue the point differently.

Why arbitration matters for fans In arbitration, a private arbitrator decides each person's claim, court review is limited and, under StubHub's terms, claims cannot be grouped into a class. A ruling for StubHub would not decide whether fans were wronged, only where and how they can pursue it.

StubHub has already won this kind of motion in a different case in the same courthouse. In a separate proposed class action filed July 13 by customer Louis Sanquini over CEO Eric Baker's ties to the ticket reseller Andro Capital, U.S. District Judge Jed S. Rakoff granted StubHub's motion to compel arbitration and paused the lawsuit, TicketNews reported on September 25.

According to that report, Rakoff found in a September 21 opinion that Sanquini agreed to StubHub's arbitration terms when he clicked the "Buy Now" button below a notice that completing a purchase meant accepting the terms. He also rejected the argument that the arbitration agreement was unconscionable under California law, citing the opt-out option and how the terms were presented. The ruling did not decide whether Sanquini's underlying claims had merit.

That decision does not bind Judge Broderick, and the World Cup buyers may make different arguments about how and when they accepted StubHub's terms. Still, it is the most direct recent example of how a judge in that court has treated StubHub's checkout terms.

Outside the United States, a Vancouver ticket buyer filed a separate proposed class action in British Columbia in July over cancelled World Cup tickets, according to TicketNews and CBC News. StubHub's U.S. and Canada arbitration clause says it does not apply to tickets for events in British Columbia.

What StubHub and FIFA have said

StubHub has said it does not comment on pending litigation, and Class Action Pulse did not find a public comment on the motion. When the first lawsuit was filed in July, a StubHub spokesperson told CBS News: "Our singular goal is to get fans into events, and if anything goes wrong, our FanProtect Guarantee provides replacement tickets or a full refund." The company added that "the issues fans have experienced are largely driven by problems with the event organizer's own ticketing infrastructure."

The original complaint also quoted StubHub telling The Guardian that the problems were "transfer problems, not ticket problems." FIFA, quoted in the same complaint, said it "rejects any suggestion" that issues on third-party platforms were the result of FIFA's ticketing infrastructure.

The court has not made any finding about who was at fault for undelivered tickets.

What happens next

The schedule set by the court is:

  • November 13, 2026: the plaintiffs' opposition to StubHub's motion is due.
  • December 4, 2026: StubHub's reply is due.

After that, Judge Broderick can rule on the papers or hold argument. There is no deadline for a decision. If he compels arbitration, the court case would likely be paused or dismissed and buyers would have to bring individual claims. If he denies arbitration, the Federal Arbitration Act lets a party appeal that denial right away, which could add months before the court turns to StubHub's dismissal arguments or class certification.

What ticket buyers can do now

If you bought World Cup tickets on StubHub and did not receive them, there is no settlement or claim form for this case. Keeping your order confirmation, emails, refund records and travel receipts can help if a class is later certified or a settlement is reached. If you have your own dispute with StubHub, the user agreement's notice and arbitration steps may affect how you pursue it, so consider getting legal advice.

You can browse other class action cases you can join. This article is general information, not legal advice.

No payout is available The case is at the motion stage. Any website or message promising StubHub World Cup refund money in exchange for personal or payment information should be treated with suspicion.

Frequently asked questions

What is the StubHub World Cup ticket lawsuit about?

It is a consolidated proposed class action in New York federal court by fans who say they bought 2026 World Cup tickets on StubHub and did not receive them as promised. The original complaint also challenged StubHub's FanProtect Guarantee promises.

What did StubHub file on October 14?

StubHub filed a motion asking the court to send the claims to arbitration or, if the court declines, to dismiss the consolidated complaint. Its detailed arguments are not yet publicly available on free court record services.

What happens if the judge grants arbitration?

Buyers would generally have to pursue their claims individually before an arbitrator. StubHub's user agreement includes a class action waiver, so the case would likely no longer proceed as a class.

When will the judge decide?

Briefing ends December 4, 2026, when StubHub's reply is due. The court has not set a date for a ruling.

Is there a StubHub World Cup settlement?

No. There is no settlement, no claim form and no payment available.

Can I opt out of StubHub arbitration now?

StubHub's terms allow an opt out by mail within 30 days of first accepting the agreement or within 30 days of notice of changes to the arbitration terms. Whether an opt out affects existing disputes is a legal question, so consider talking to a lawyer.