Overview
- Alleged issue
- DMV lookups used to mail private parking invoices
- Who
- Drivers invoiced by Municipal Parking or Premium Parking
- Case
- No. 8:25-cv-2920, M.D. Fla., Judge Mizelle
- Stage
- Dismissal denied Nov. 5, 2026. No class or settlement
Two Florida drivers say private parking companies used their license plates to pull their names and home addresses from state motor vehicle records, then mailed them parking invoices threatening booting or towing. They claim this violated the federal Driver's Privacy Protection Act, and they are suing on behalf of a proposed class.
The case is Levine v. Municipal Parking Services, Inc., No. 8:25-cv-2920, in the U.S. District Court for the Middle District of Florida in Tampa. On November 5, 2026, Judge Kathryn Kimball Mizelle denied the defendants' motions to dismiss, ruling that the drivers have standing and have stated a claim. The defendants must answer the amended complaint by November 19, 2026.
The ruling lets the case move forward. It does not decide who is right, and no class has been certified. There is no settlement or claim form.
Who the parties are
Steve Levine and Jaquelyn Deppe are the plaintiffs. Both live in Pinellas County, Florida, according to the court's order.
Municipal Parking Services, Inc. and Premium Parking Service, LLC are defendants. The amended complaint says they operate private parking enforcement programs at parking facilities throughout Florida and other states.
GovCIO, LLC is the third defendant. The plaintiffs say it provides parking enforcement technology, including looking up registered owners in motor vehicle records and passing names and addresses to the parking companies and their mailing vendors.
Judge Kathryn Kimball Mizelle is presiding.
The court order we reviewed does not name the plaintiffs' lawyers.
What happened
According to the amended complaint, as summarized in the court's order:
- April 26, 2025: Deppe twice drove through a private lot in Redington Shores, Florida, run by Municipal Parking and Premium Parking, to drop off and pick up family members. She never parked. Days later she received an invoice that claimed her vehicle "had been parked for nearly four hours" and threatened booting or towing.
- October 7, 2025: Levine's daughter parked his vehicle in the same lot. Levine later received an invoice at his home from companies he had never dealt with, threatening that his vehicle could be booted or towed.
- October 2025: Levine sued Municipal Parking Services.
- May 2026: An amended complaint added Deppe as a plaintiff and Premium Parking and GovCIO as defendants. It has three counts, one against each defendant, all under the DPPA.
- November 5, 2026: The court denied both motions to dismiss.
The plaintiffs say neither of them gave the companies their names or addresses, signed a consent or created an account. They say the lookups happened after their vehicles left the lot, as part of a standardized, automated invoicing process.
What each side says
The drivers' position. The plaintiffs claim the companies obtained and used personal information from motor vehicle records without a purpose the law allows. They say the invoices called themselves invoices, did not threaten a lawsuit and stated they were not subject to civil penalties, and that the companies do not sue to collect these charges. They say they suffered privacy injuries and lost time trying to understand how the companies found them.
The companies' position. The defendants argued that the drivers have no injury that a federal court can hear, and that their lookups were allowed as "investigation in anticipation of litigation" because they could sue over unpaid parking charges. GovCIO also argued that any harm from the mailed invoices was not traceable to it, because it did not send them. We found no public statement from any defendant.
What the court has and has not decided
The court decided two things at the pleading stage, accepting the complaint's allegations as true:
- Standing: Both drivers alleged a concrete privacy injury from the retrieval of their records, and Levine alleged a second injury from receiving the invoice at home. The judge found these resemble the traditional privacy harm of intrusion upon seclusion, noting that courts in the region are split on unwanted mail.
- The claim: Relying on the Supreme Court's 2013 decision in Maracich v. Spears, the judge looked at the companies' predominant purpose and found that, as alleged, it was invoicing, not investigating for a lawsuit. She wrote that a lawyer's demand letter or proof of actual collection suits "might" have led to a different outcome.
The court has not found that any company broke the law. It has not decided whether a class should be certified, what the class would be or whether anyone is owed money.
Who may qualify
- Invoice: You got a mailed private parking invoice from Municipal Parking Services or Premium Parking.
- No relationship: You never gave those companies your name or home address.
- Lookup: You were identified through your license plate and a state motor vehicle record.
- Status: The proposed class definition was not available to us, and no class is certified.
No class has been certified, and we were not able to review the proposed class definition in the amended complaint. Based on the claims described in the court's order, people most likely to be affected are:
- Invoice recipients: People who received a mailed private parking invoice or notice from Municipal Parking Services or Premium Parking.
- No prior relationship: People who never gave those companies their name or address.
- Lookup through plates: People who were identified through a license plate and a state motor vehicle record.
- Location: The order says the companies operate in Florida and other states. Whether the proposed class reaches beyond Florida is not stated in the order.
What affected readers can do now
- Keep any invoice you received. Save the envelope, the invoice and any photos or plate details it shows.
- Note the lot and the date. Write down where you were, how long you stayed and whether you parked.
- Keep payment records. If you paid, save the receipt or bank statement.
- Do not ignore a real court paper. This lawsuit does not decide whether any specific parking charge is valid. Get advice before ignoring a demand.
- Watch for official notice. If a class is certified or a settlement is reached, class members would be notified.
- Send an inquiry if you want. A Class Action Pulse inquiry is only an inquiry. It does not join the lawsuit or create a lawyer relationship.
What you could receive
Save your invoice
Keep the invoice, envelope, lot location, date and any payment records.
$2,500 minimum per violation
The DPPA allows actual damages of at least $2,500, plus punitive damages and fees. Nothing has been awarded.
Claim form
There is no settlement or claim process. Class members would get notice if one is created.
No money is available now. There is no settlement, judgment or claim form.
The DPPA lets a person sue for actual damages, but not less than liquidated damages of $2,500, plus punitive damages for willful or reckless violations, attorneys' fees and other relief a court finds appropriate. That is what the statute allows, as quoted by the court. It is not a promise of what anyone in this case will receive, and we did not see the complaint's own request for relief.
Important dates and rights
- October 2025: Original complaint filed.
- May 2026: Amended complaint filed.
- November 5, 2026: Motions to dismiss denied.
- November 19, 2026: Deadline for the defendants to answer the amended complaint.
There are no claim, opt-out or objection deadlines. Opt-out rights would come only with a certified class or settlement.
Definitions
Driver's Privacy Protection Act (DPPA): A 1994 federal law that limits how personal information in state motor vehicle records can be obtained, disclosed and used.
Motor vehicle record: A state record about a driver's license, title, registration or ID card.
Permissible use: One of the 14 purposes for which the DPPA allows motor vehicle record information to be used.
Standing: The requirement that a plaintiff show a real injury before a federal court can hear the case.
Motion to dismiss: A request to throw out a case before evidence is exchanged, usually arguing the complaint fails legally.
Liquidated damages: A fixed amount set by statute that can be awarded without proving the exact loss.
What happens next
The defendants must file their answers by November 19, 2026. The case then moves toward evidence exchange and, later, a request to certify a class. Any payment would come only from a later court-approved settlement or judgment.
A separate DPPA class action against Municipal Parking Services was filed in Alabama federal court in 2024 by a different firm, Pittman, Dutton, Hellums, Bradley & Mann. That case, Nelson v. Municipal Parking Services, closed in August 2024, and the public docket summary does not say how. The firm's website says it is also investigating Premium Parking.
Class Action Pulse will update this page as the case moves forward.
Sources and evidence boundaries
This page relies on the court's November 5, 2026 order, with coverage from Bloomberg Law, Law360 and a law firm blog as cross-checks, and on the docket listing and complaint for the 2024 Alabama case.
We could not access the amended complaint, so the proposed class definition, the relief requested and the plaintiffs' lawyers are not reported. Facts about the plaintiffs come from the order's summary of their allegations, which are unproven. We did not confirm whether Pittman Dutton is involved in the Florida case.
Class Action Pulse is not a law firm or settlement administrator and does not guarantee eligibility or payment. This article is general information, not legal advice.
Frequently asked questions
What did the judge decide?
That the drivers have standing and stated a DPPA claim, so the case continues. The court did not find the companies broke the law.
Does this cancel my parking charge?
No. The lawsuit does not decide whether any specific parking charge is valid.
Is the case limited to Florida?
The order says the companies operate in Florida and other states but does not state the proposed class's reach.
Can I get money now?
No. There is no settlement or judgment, and no class has been certified.
Sources
- Order denying motions to dismiss (Nov. 5, 2026), M.D. Fla. No. 8:25-cv-2920
- Bloomberg Law: parking lot operators stuck with privacy suit (Nov. 6, 2026)
- Law360: parking lot operators stuck with Fla. suit over DMV records
- Consumer Nation (Garrett Berg): analysis of the standing ruling
- Docket summary, Nelson v. Municipal Parking Services, N.D. Ala. No. 2:24-cv-00913
- Pittman Dutton: Municipal Parking Services DPPA page

