Check Your Claims
Legal News Consumer

Target mac and cheese lawsuit says Good & Gather and Market Pantry no preservatives labels mislead

A New York shopper filed a proposed class action on October 22, 2026, claiming Target's Good & Gather and Market Pantry boxed mac and cheese carry no preservatives or no artificial preservatives labels despite containing ingredients the complaint calls preservatives. Target has not responded, nothing is proven and there is no claim form.

By Class Action Pulse Staff Published

Reported from primary sources · Verified against official filings and settlement records.

Estimated reading time: 7 minutes.

Key facts

  • Case: Vaughan v. Target Corporation, No. 7:26-cv-09281, U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York.
  • Filed: October 22, 2026, by a Westchester County, New York, shopper represented by Reese LLP.
  • Products: Target's Market Pantry and Good & Gather boxed macaroni and cheese, including spirals, shells and white cheddar varieties.
  • The claim: labels say "No Preservatives" or "No Artificial Preservatives," but the complaint says the products contain citric acid, lactic acid powder and/or sodium phosphate, which it calls preservatives.
  • Who it could cover: proposed nationwide and New York classes of people who bought the products.
  • Status: a newly filed proposed class action. Target has not filed a response, no court has ruled on the claims and there is no settlement or claim form.

In this article

A New York shopper has filed a proposed class action claiming Target sold its store-brand macaroni and cheese with "no preservatives" labels even though, according to the complaint, the boxes list ingredients that work as preservatives.

The case, Vaughan v. Target Corporation, was filed October 22, 2026, in federal court in New York. It targets two of Target's own brands: Market Pantry, its budget grocery line, and Good & Gather, the food brand Target introduced in 2019. Everything described below comes from the complaint and is an allegation. Target has not answered in court, and nothing has been proven.

What the lawsuit claims

The plaintiff, Kiana Vaughan, says she bought Good & Gather macaroni and cheese, mainly the White Cheddar and Shells & White Cheddar varieties, at Target stores in Westchester County for about three years, ending around the fall of 2025. She says she relied on the "No Preservatives" or "No Artificial Preservatives" statements and would not have bought the products, or would have paid less, if she had known what was inside.

According to the complaint, the front labels on the products carry one of these statements:

  • "NO Artificial Flavors, Preservatives, or Synthetic Colors"
  • "No Artificial Preservatives"
  • "No Preservatives"

The complaint says this messaging often appears in bold type or against a different colored background. It argues that shoppers read these phrases to mean the food contains no preservatives at all. It says many consumers try to avoid preservatives and are willing to pay more for foods free of them, so the claims gave Target an unfair advantage at the shelf.

It also argues that the Good & Gather name itself adds to the impression. Quoting a 2019 Target press release, the complaint says Target promoted the brand as one that prioritizes "taste, quality ingredients, and ease." Some Good & Gather boxes also say "Made with Organic Pasta," which the complaint says reinforces a natural, minimally processed message.

These are allegations, not findings A complaint tells one side of the story. Target has not filed its defense, and a judge has not decided whether the labels were misleading or whether the ingredients act as preservatives in these products.

Which products are named

The complaint lists these Target products:

  • Market Pantry Macaroni & Cheese
  • Market Pantry Macaroni & Cheese Spirals
  • Market Pantry Deluxe Shells Macaroni & Cheese
  • Good & Gather White Cheddar Macaroni & Cheese
  • Good & Gather Shells & Aged Cheddar Macaroni and Cheese
  • Good & Gather Shells & White Cheddar Macaroni & Cheese
  • Good & Gather Elbows & Classic Cheddar Macaroni & Cheese
  • Good & Gather Macaroni & Cheese

According to the complaint, one pictured Market Pantry product lists all three challenged ingredients, while the other pictured products list lactic acid powder and sodium phosphate. The complaint does not name other Target foods.

Why citric acid and sodium phosphate are at issue

The complaint says the products contain one or more of three ingredients: citric acid, lactic acid powder and sodium phosphate. Its argument depends on a federal definition.

Under Food and Drug Administration rules, a "chemical preservative" means "any chemical that, when added to food, tends to prevent or retard deterioration thereof." The same rule, 21 C.F.R. 101.22(a)(5), excludes common salt, sugars, vinegars, spices and a few other items. Citric acid, lactic acid and sodium phosphate are not on that exclusion list.

The complaint makes several points about these ingredients:

  • Citric acid: it cites a 2010 FDA warning letter that said Chiquita's "Pineapple Bites" contained "the chemical preservatives ascorbic acid and citric acid" without labels describing their function. It also says citric acid works as a preservative at about 0.03% of a product, while its sourness is not detected until about 0.04%, which it uses to argue the ingredient is not there just for flavor.
  • Lactic acid powder: the complaint says it is widely used as an antimicrobial agent that inhibits the microorganisms that cause spoilage, and that the FDA lists "antimicrobial agent" among its technical effects in food.
  • Sodium phosphate: the complaint says it is used to control acidity and inhibit spoilage microorganisms, and that the FDA recognizes sodium phosphates as approved additives for effects such as pH control.

The lawsuit also anticipates a likely defense. Target could argue that its labels say "no artificial preservatives" and that these ingredients are not artificial. The complaint responds that about 99% of citric acid today is made with a fungus called Aspergillus niger in an industrial fermentation process, rather than taken from citrus fruit, and that shoppers are never told where the ingredient came from. It says reasonable consumers do not draw technical lines between artificial and naturally derived preservatives.

How much of each ingredient is in the boxes, and what job each one actually does in the recipe, are factual questions the complaint does not answer with test results. It relies on the ingredient lists and on the plaintiff's information and belief. Those questions would likely be central if the case moves forward.

Look at the ingredient list, not just the front panel If preservatives matter to you, the ingredient statement on the back or side of the box is the most complete source. Front-of-box claims are marketing language, and lawsuits like this one test how they should be read.

The complaint brings three counts:

  • Two counts under New York General Business Law: the complaint relies on the state ban on deceptive business practices (section 349) and its false advertising law (section 350), on behalf of the New York class. It says damages for each class member will not be less than $50.
  • Unjust enrichment: a claim, on behalf of both proposed classes, that Target kept money it should not have kept because of the labels.

It asks the court to certify two groups:

  • Nationwide class: all persons who bought the products in the United States within the applicable statute of limitations period.
  • New York class: all persons who bought the products in New York within that period.

People who assert personal injury claims and people who bought the products for resale are excluded, along with Target and its affiliates. The complaint asks for restitution, disgorgement of profits, actual, statutory and punitive damages, attorneys' fees and a jury trial. It says the total amount in dispute is more than $5 million, which allows the case to be heard in federal court.

These class definitions are proposals. A judge would have to certify a class before anyone is formally part of the case, and that is often decided much later, if at all.

What Target has said

Class Action Pulse did not find a public statement from Target about this lawsuit. The Independent reported on November 7 that it had contacted Target for comment, and its report did not include a response.

The same report noted that Target faces a separate lawsuit, filed in March 2026, over sustainability claims on Good & Gather canned tuna. That case is unrelated to the macaroni and cheese labels.

For other cases that may be open to shoppers now, see our list of class action cases you can join.

No claim form exists There is no settlement and no payment process for this lawsuit. Be wary of any website that asks for personal or payment details in exchange for a Target mac and cheese payout.

What happens next

The next step is for Target to respond to the complaint. In food labeling cases, companies often file a motion to dismiss arguing that a reasonable shopper would not be misled or that the ingredients serve purposes other than preservation. If the case survives, the parties would gather evidence, including how the ingredients function in these recipes, before any class certification ruling.

You can follow the case and check who it may cover on our Target mac and cheese lawsuit page. If you bought any of the listed products, there is nothing you need to do right now. Keeping receipts or order history could help if a settlement or certified class is announced later. This article is general information, not legal advice.

Frequently asked questions

What is the Target mac and cheese lawsuit about?

A proposed class action filed October 22, 2026, claims Target labeled its Market Pantry and Good & Gather macaroni and cheese as having no preservatives or no artificial preservatives while the products contain citric acid, lactic acid powder and/or sodium phosphate.

Which Target products are included?

The complaint names three Market Pantry products and five Good & Gather products, including spirals, shells, white cheddar, aged cheddar and classic cheddar varieties. The full list is in the products section above.

Are citric acid and sodium phosphate preservatives?

The complaint argues they meet the FDA definition of a chemical preservative because they can slow spoilage. Target has not yet responded, and a court has not decided how these ingredients function in these products.

Is there a Target mac and cheese settlement?

No. The case was just filed. There is no settlement, no claim form and no money available.

Who could be part of the case?

The complaint proposes a nationwide class of U.S. buyers and a New York class. A judge must certify a class before anyone is formally included.

Has Target responded?

Class Action Pulse did not find a public response. The Independent said it contacted Target for comment and did not report a reply.