Check Your Claims
SettlementsConsumerAccepting claimants

Target Good & Gather and Market Pantry mac and cheese 'no preservatives' lawsuit (Vaughan v. Target)

A proposed class action says Target labels eight Good & Gather and Market Pantry mac and cheese products as having no artificial preservatives while they contain citric acid, lactic acid or sodium phosphate. Nothing proven.

Updated November 8, 2026

Defendant
Target Corporation
Status
Accepting claimants
Potential compensation
If the case succeeds or settles
How to join
Accepting claimants now
Case type
Active lawsuit
Court
U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York
Case number
7:26-cv-09281
Check if you qualify

Overview

Alleged issue
'No artificial preservatives' label on products with citric acid, lactic acid or sodium phosphate
Products
5 Good & Gather and 3 Market Pantry boxed mac and cheese items
Filed
October 22, 2026, S.D. New York
Stage
No response, ruling or settlement yet

A New York shopper has filed a proposed class action claiming Target labels eight of its store-brand boxed macaroni and cheese products as free of preservatives even though their ingredient lists include citric acid, lactic acid powder or sodium phosphate.

The case is Vaughan v. Target Corporation, No. 7:26-cv-09281, filed October 22, 2026, in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York. It covers Good & Gather and Market Pantry mac and cheese and seeks to represent buyers across the United States, with a separate group for New York buyers.

The lawsuit is at its first step. Target has not answered in court, no judge has ruled on the claims, and there is no settlement, payment or claim form.

Who the parties are

Target Corporation is the national retail chain. The complaint describes it as a Minnesota corporation headquartered in Minneapolis. Good & Gather and Market Pantry are Target's own store brands. When Target launched Good & Gather in 2019, it called it its "largest owned Food & Beverage brand" and said the products are made without artificial flavors, artificial sweeteners, synthetic colors and high fructose corn syrup. The same announcement said Target would reduce the number of Market Pantry products.

The eight products named in the complaint are:

  • Good & Gather: White Cheddar Macaroni & Cheese, Shells & Aged Cheddar Macaroni and Cheese, Shells & White Cheddar Macaroni & Cheese, Elbows & Classic Cheddar Macaroni & Cheese, and Macaroni & Cheese.
  • Market Pantry: Macaroni & Cheese, Macaroni & Cheese Spirals, and Deluxe Shells Macaroni & Cheese.

Kiana Vaughan is the named plaintiff. The complaint says she lives in Westchester County, New York, and bought the products for about three years, ending around fall 2025. She says she mainly bought Good & Gather White Cheddar and Shells & White Cheddar, sometimes buying yellow cheddar versions, near her home.

Her lawyers are Carlos F. Ramirez and Michael R. Reese of Reese LLP in New York.

The court is the federal trial court for the Southern District of New York. The case number's "7" prefix points to the White Plains courthouse. The docket reviewed did not name a judge.

What happened

According to the complaint, the court docket and news coverage:

  • August 19, 2019: Target announced Good & Gather as its new flagship food brand.
  • Through fall 2025: Vaughan bought the products for about three years, ending around fall 2025, according to her complaint.
  • October 22, 2026: Vaughan filed the complaint with a jury demand, along with a civil cover sheet and a request for a summons.
  • November 6 and 7, 2026: Top Class Actions and The Independent reported on the lawsuit.

What each side says

Vaughan alleges the boxes say "NO Artificial Flavors, Preservatives, or Synthetic Colors" or "No Artificial Preservatives," but the products contain "the known preservatives citric acid, lactic acid powder and/or sodium phosphate." She claims:

  • Citric acid: It is a common food preservative. About 99% of today's supply is made with the fungus Aspergillus niger, not squeezed from fruit. She cites a 2010 Food and Drug Administration warning letter to Chiquita that called citric acid a chemical preservative in a fruit product.
  • Lactic acid powder: The FDA lists it as having a technical effect as an "antimicrobial agent," meaning it slows the growth of microbes that cause spoilage.
  • Sodium phosphate: It controls acidity, which she says helps extend shelf life.

She argues the word "artificial" does not fix the problem, because "reasonable consumers do not draw technical distinctions between 'artificial' and 'naturally derived' preservatives." She also says the "Good & Gather" name and "Made with Organic Pasta" wording make the products seem healthier. She claims she would not have bought them, or would not have paid a premium, without the preservative claim.

Target's position is not on record. Target has not filed a response, and Class Action Pulse found no public statement about the case. The defenses it may raise are unknown.

Federal sources point both ways. An FDA consumer page lists citric acid as an example of a preservative, but it also lists citric acid and lactic acid as acidity control agents and notes that "some additives are used for more than one purpose." Federal rules define a chemical preservative by its function: any chemical that "tends to prevent or retard deterioration" of food. Whether these ingredients do that in Target's recipes, and whether they are "artificial," are questions the court would have to resolve.

What the court has and has not decided

The court has decided nothing. It has not ruled on whether the labels are false or misleading, whether the ingredients act as preservatives in these products, or whether the case can go forward as a class action.

Who may qualify

  • Product: You bought one of the eight named Good & Gather or Market Pantry mac and cheese products.
  • Location: Proposed nationwide class, plus a New York group.
  • Timing: Purchases within the applicable time limit for claims.
  • Not certified: No court has approved a class.

The complaint proposes two groups:

  • Nationwide: Everyone who bought the named products in the United States within the applicable time limit for claims.
  • New York: Everyone who bought the products in New York within that time limit.
  • Products: The five Good & Gather and three Market Pantry mac and cheese items listed above.
  • Excluded: Target and its affiliates, officers and directors, people who bought for resale, people who opt out, the judge and immediate family, and anyone asserting a personal injury claim.

A judge must certify a class before anyone is formally part of the case.

What affected readers can do now

  1. Check your pantry. Look for the "No Artificial Preservatives" or "No Artificial Flavors, Preservatives or Synthetic Colors" wording on Good & Gather or Market Pantry boxes.
  2. Save proof. Keep receipts, Target Circle or Target.com order history, or photos of the box and ingredient list.
  3. Write down your purchase history. Note which products you bought, about how often and in which state.
  4. Watch for notices. If a class is certified or a settlement is reached, buyers are usually notified.
  5. Send an inquiry if you want. The form on this page sends your details to Class Action Pulse. It does not join the lawsuit.

What you could receive

Sought

Refunds and damages

The complaint seeks restitution, actual, statutory and punitive damages, and at least $50 under New York consumer law.

Sought

Class notice

It also asks the court to make Target pay to notify class members and to cover attorneys' fees.

No fund

No settlement yet

There is no settlement, payment or claim deadline. Any money would need court approval.

No money is available now. The complaint asks for restitution and disgorgement of profits, actual, statutory and punitive damages, attorneys' fees and interest, and an order making Target pay to notify class members. For the New York consumer law claim, it says damages should be no less than $50. That is the plaintiff's request, not an award.

Important dates and rights

  • October 22, 2026: Complaint filed.
  • No claim deadline: There is no settlement or claim process.

You do not need to do anything now to stay in a possible future class.

Definitions

Preservative: An ingredient that helps prevent food from spoiling. Federal rules define chemical preservatives by what they do.

Citric acid: A common acid used for tartness, acidity control and preservation.

Sodium phosphate: A salt used in processed foods. The complaint says it controls acidity.

General Business Law sections 349 and 350: New York's laws against deceptive business practices and false advertising.

Unjust enrichment: A claim that a company kept money it should not fairly keep.

Putative class: A group a plaintiff proposes to represent before a judge approves it.

What happens next

Target must be served and then respond, typically with an answer or a motion to dismiss. In "no preservatives" cases, courts often weigh whether an ingredient actually serves a preservative function in the product and what a reasonable shopper would understand from the label.

Target has faced similar claims before. In 2024, Bloomberg Law reported a proposed class action in California federal court, Carbine v. Target, No. 2:24-cv-03721, challenging a "No Artificial Colors, Flavors, or Preservatives" label on Good & Gather pasta sauces that contain citric acid. Top Class Actions also reports a separate suit over Good & Gather tuna. Those are different cases, and their outcomes do not decide this one.

Sources and evidence boundaries

This article relies on the complaint, the federal court docket, Target's 2019 Good & Gather announcement, FDA's food ingredient guide, the federal labeling rule for chemical preservatives, and coverage by Top Class Actions, The Independent and Bloomberg Law.

Exact label wording on each box, ingredient lists for every product and the assigned judge were not independently confirmed. The Carbine case details come from Bloomberg Law's 2024 report, and its later outcome was not reviewed. All claims are the plaintiff's allegations.

Class Action Pulse is not a law firm or settlement administrator and does not guarantee eligibility or payment. This article is general information, not legal advice.

Frequently asked questions

Which Target mac and cheese products are named?

Five Good & Gather items, including White Cheddar and Shells & Aged Cheddar, and three Market Pantry items, including Spirals and Deluxe Shells.

Is the mac and cheese unsafe?

No safety claim is made. The lawsuit is about labeling, and anyone asserting a personal injury claim is excluded from the class.

Are citric acid and lactic acid preservatives?

FDA materials list them as preservatives or acidity regulators, depending on use. The court would decide what they do in these products.

Do I have to live in New York?

No. The complaint proposes a nationwide class, with a separate New York group for the state law claims.

Sources

This case is still developing and has no official claim site yet. Class Action Pulse is not a law firm — submit your details below to be notified and connected with a firm handling the case.

Free eligibility check

Do you qualify?

Check your eligibility and get help understanding your claim. It's free and takes under a minute.

Class Action Pulse is not a law firm and does not provide legal advice. Submitting this form does not create an attorney–client relationship. This is attorney advertising.